• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Scarsella's Restaurant

Located in Youngstown, Ohio, Scarsella's Restaurant is a cherished family-owned eatery that specializes in authentic homemade Italian cuisine. Renowned for its delicious offerings, the restaurant boasts outstanding dishes like crispy veal Parm and the best meatballs in town, according to satisfied customers. With a cozy, welcoming atmosphere, Scarsella’s is perfect for families seeking hearty portions without breaking the bank. The gluten-free pasta option adds to the appeal, ensuring everyone can enjoy the rich flavors. Diners rave about the attentive service and consistent quality, making Scarsella’s a must-visit destination for Italian food enthusiasts.

Scarsella's Restaurant: Reviews & Ratings

Donna Lohnes
Donna Lohnes

Oh my! The homemade pasta was wonderful. The best meatballs I've ever had and I love meatballs. The veal Parm was so crispy, even under the wonderful sauce. The food came out very hot not lukewarm. They even have a gluten free pasta option! I'll be back to try different items!

JD Tango
JD Tango

No frills, just great home-made Italian food. I love the family atmosphere. Meatballs are the best around. I always take an order to go!

Lori Zorn
Lori Zorn

Nice, family-owned business. Traveling through Ohio to get home in PA, stopped here for dinner. Standard prices, not really high at all. Great portions, tasty homemade food, nice staff!

Lydia Luke
Lydia Luke

Great meal for homemade Italian food! Quiet, small restaurant with plenty of options for lunch/dinner. Ditch Olive Garden, and give this mom n dad shop a try!

Jenna Acierno
Jenna Acierno

One of my absolute favorite restaurants!! Have been coming here with my family for years and it never disappoints. All of the food is amazing. Very family friendly atmosphere and the staff is always nice and so welcoming. 10/10 would recommend this place to anyone looking for authentic Italian food and a great dining experience!

SocialMedia Team
SocialMedia Team

The food is always so good and relatively quickly served. The service is excellent. You can’t go wrong if you’re craving Italian food!

Carrie0603
Carrie0603

Nice little family owned restaurant with very good food. I tried the chicken Parm with the vodka sauce. I like that it comes with shells as the pasta instead of spaghetti noodles like most other places.

Dara
Dara

Mmm!! Had the BEST pasta yesterday...I mean, REALLY!! I ordered shells w pepper sauce n have NEVER eaten more than half in 1 sitting, I couldn't stop. THIS is why I NEVER, EVER order pasta anywhere else!

Location

Welcome to Scarsella's Restaurant, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Youngstown, Ohio. Located at 4151 Market St, this charming family-owned eatery offers a delightful escape into the world of homemade Italian cuisine. Whether you're a local or just passing through, Scarsella's promises a comforting dining experience that feels like a warm embrace.

At Scarsella's, the love for food is evident in every dish. Guests rave about the homemade pasta, a staple that elevates the dining experience to new heights. Donna Lohnes couldn't help but sing praises for it, declaring the homemade pasta and the meatballs to be among the best she's ever had. Indeed, the meatballs have carved a niche for themselves as a signature dish, winning over numerous fans, including JD Tango, who appreciates both their taste and the family-friendly atmosphere.

The veal parmesan, noted for its crispy texture, has also left diners impressed. This dish, complemented by a savory sauce, comes fresh and piping hot, ensuring that every bite offers authentic flavors. Scarsella's even caters to diverse dietary needs with gluten-free pasta options, allowing everyone to indulge in the joys of Italian cooking.

As you step inside, expect a cozy, no-frills ambiance that focuses on great food and family values. Lori Zorn's visit highlights how Scarsella's achieves an incredible balance between affordability and large portions, making it accessible for everyone without compromising on quality. It's this essence that sets Scarsella's apart from other dining establishments.

The restaurant fosters a sense of community that resonates deeply with many patrons. Jenna Acierno, a loyal customer, emphasizes how it feels like home every time she visits, making family outings a cherished ritual. Each smile from the staff welcomes you, reinforcing the familial spirit that lingers in the air.

For those seeking a genuine Italian dining experience, Scarsella's Restaurant is a must-visit. The combination of delightful dishes, a welcoming atmosphere, and a commitment to quality and tradition make it a place worth returning to time and again. So, why settle for chain restaurants when you can savor the true essence of Italy right here in Youngstown?